Let be a polygon whose vertices have been colored (labeled) cyclically with the numbers . Motivated by conjectures of Propp, we are led to consider partitions of into -gons which are proper in the sense that each -gon contains all colors on its vertices. Counting the number of proper partitions involves a generalization of the -Catalan numbers. We also show that in certain cases, any proper partition can be obtained from another by a sequence of moves called flips.