On the Various Energy Forms of the Join of Complete Graphs

Arooj Ibrahim1, Saima Nazeer1
1Lahore College for Women University, Lahore 54000, Pakistan

Abstract

The concept of graph energy, first introduced in 1978, has been a focal point of extensive research within the field of graph theory, leading to the publication of numerous articles. Graph energy, originally associated with the eigenvalues of the adjacency matrix of a graph, has since been extended to various other matrices. These include the maximum degree matrix, Randić matrix, sum-connectivity matrix, and the first and second Zagreb matrices, among others. In this paper, we focus on calculating the energy of several such matrices for the join graph of complete graphs, denoted as Jm(Kn). Specifically, we compute the energies for the maximum degree matrix, Randić matrix, sum-connectivity matrix, first Zagreb matrix, second Zagreb matrix, reverse first Zagreb matrix, and reverse second Zagreb matrix for Jm(Kn). Our results provide new insights into the structural properties of the join graph and contribute to the broader understanding of the mathematical characteristics of graph energy for different matrix representations. This work extends the scope of graph energy research by considering these alternative matrix forms, offering a deeper exploration into the algebraic and spectral properties of graph energy in the context of join graphs.

Keywords: Graph energy, Join graph, Complete graph, Maximum degree matrix, Randić matrix, Sum-connectivity matrix, Zagreb matrix, Spectral graph theory, Matrix energy, Graph theory

1. Introduction

Discrete mathematics, a branch of mathematics dealing with discrete objects rather than continuous, encompasses various sub-fields, among which graph theory has garnered significant attention. Within this domain, the concept of graph energy has emerged as a pivotal area of study. Graph theory provides an intuitive approach to problem-solving by abstracting real-world systems into graphical models. This abstraction enables researchers to apply combinatorial and algebraic techniques to address complex issues across numerous disciplines. The growing prominence of graph energy reflects its utility in providing insights and solutions to problems that span beyond traditional mathematical boundaries.

Graph theory’s versatility is evident in its diverse applications, which range from natural sciences to engineering. The concept of graph energy has been leveraged in various scientific and technological contexts, demonstrating its far-reaching impact. For instance, graph energies have found applications in fields such as air travel optimization and spacecraft construction [1], where they aid in the analysis and design of efficient systems. Additionally, graph energy principles have been utilized in facial recognition technologies and satellite communication systems [2], highlighting their relevance in modern technological advancements. A comprehensive overview of the applications and significance of graph energies is presented in [3], which underscores the broad scope of research in this area.

The foundational concept of graph energy was introduced by Ivan Gutman in 1978 [4], inspired by quantum chemistry. This idea drew from the work of E. Huckel, who, in 1930, applied graph theory to chemical structures through his molecular orbital theory for Π-electron networks in conjugated hydrocarbons. Huckel’s approach led to the development of characteristic polynomials and the subsequent determination of eigenvalues [5]. The application of matrix analysis to graph theory, as explored by Horn [6] and Gantmakher [7], has further enriched the study of graph energy. Bapat’s work [8] demonstrated that the energy of a graph cannot be an odd integer, adding a significant constraint to the theoretical understanding of graph energy.

Further research has expanded the knowledge of graph energies in various contexts. For example, [9] explored the energies of specific classes of non-regular graphs, while [10] established that the energy of a graph cannot be the square root of an odd integer. Nikiforov’s research [11] provided bounds for the energies of different graph structures, contributing to the broader understanding of energy distributions across graph types. Meenakshi [12] compiled a comprehensive survey of energies for regular, non-regular, circulant, and random graphs, providing valuable insights into the diverse behaviors of graph energies.

Recent studies have furthered the analysis of various energy measures. For instance, [13] defined the maximum degree energy of a graph and provided results for its bounds, while [14] detailed numerous applications of graph theory within Computer Science and Engineering. The derivation of bounds for graph energy E(G) is explored in [15], and [16] provided upper and lower bounds for Zagreb energy. Jaferi’s work [17] established a relationship between Zagreb energy and Zagreb Estrada index, while [18] analyzed the eigenvalues of the sum-connectivity matrix. The definition and bounds for Randić energy were examined in [19], and the study of Sombor matrix and energy was expanded by [20] and [21]. Research into the average degree eigenvalues and energies of graph families [22], reverse Laplacian energy [23], and reverse maximum degree energy [24] has further contributed to the comprehensive understanding of graph energy measures.

This paper aims to build upon this extensive body of work by computing various energy measures for the join graph of complete graphs. By examining the maximum degree matrix, Randić matrix, sum-connectivity matrix, and several Zagreb matrices, this study seeks to advance the theoretical understanding of graph energy and its applications. The results presented herein will contribute to the broader field of graph theory and its numerous applications across scientific and technological domains.

2. Methodology

In this study, we investigate the energy measures of several matrices associated with the join graph of complete graphs, denoted as Jm(Kn). The various matrices under consideration include the maximum degree matrix, Randić matrix, sum-connectivity matrix, first Zagreb matrix, second Zagreb matrix, reverse first Zagreb matrix, and reverse second Zagreb matrix. This section outlines the methodology for computing these energy measures.

2.1 Join Graph of Complete Graphs

The join graph Jm(Kn) is constructed by taking m disjoint copies of the complete graph Kn and joining each vertex in one copy with every vertex in the other copies. This results in a graph where each pair of vertices from different copies is connected by an edge, while vertices within the same copy form a complete subgraph. Formally, if Kn has n vertices, then Jm(Kn) will have mn vertices and m(m1)2n2+mn(n1)2 edges.

2.2 Maximum Degree Matrix

The maximum degree matrix Dmax is a diagonal matrix where each diagonal entry corresponds to the maximum degree of the vertices in the graph. For Jm(Kn), the maximum degree of each vertex is (m1)n+(n1). Hence, each diagonal entry in Dmax is (m1)n+(n1), and all off-diagonal entries are zero.

2.3 Randić Matrix

The Randić matrix R is defined as a matrix where each entry rij is given by rij=1didj if vertices i and j are adjacent, and zero otherwise. Here, di and dj represent the degrees of vertices i and j respectively. For Jm(Kn), the degrees are uniform across the graph, simplifying the calculation of the Randić matrix.

2.4 Sum-Connectivity Matrix

The sum-connectivity matrix S is defined such that each entry sij equals 2di+dj if vertices i and j are adjacent, and zero otherwise. The calculation of this matrix involves determining the degree of each vertex, which, as in the Randić matrix, are uniform for the join graph Jm(Kn).

2.5 Zagreb Matrices

The first Zagreb matrix Z1 is a diagonal matrix where each diagonal entry is the sum of the squares of the degrees of the corresponding vertex. The second Zagreb matrix Z2 is defined such that each entry zij is 1didj if vertices i and j are adjacent, and zero otherwise. The reverse first Zagreb matrix Z1r and reverse second Zagreb matrix Z2r are computed similarly but involve reciprocal degree calculations in reverse order.

2.6 Energy Calculations

The energy of a graph G associated with a matrix M is computed using the eigenvalues of M. Specifically, the energy E(M) is given by the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of M. For each matrix considered in this study, we calculate its eigenvalues and then sum their absolute values to obtain the energy.

2.7 Computational Approach

The computations for matrix construction and energy calculations are performed using Python and MATLAB. We utilize numerical libraries and matrix computation functions to handle the large matrices involved and ensure precision in the results. For each type of matrix and corresponding energy measure, we verify the results through multiple iterations and consistency checks.

This methodology provides a comprehensive approach to analyzing various energy measures for the join graph of complete graphs, contributing valuable insights into its spectral properties and overall behavior.

3. Preliminaries

Graph theory, a key area within discrete mathematics, provides a robust framework for analyzing and understanding complex networks. In this study, we consider a simple, undirected, and finite graph G, characterized by its vertex set V(G)={v1,v2,v3,,vp} and edge set E(G)={e1,e2,e3,,eq}. Each vertex v in graph G is associated with a degree dv, which represents the number of edges incident to v [25]. The maximum degree of G, denoted as Δ(G), is the highest degree among all vertices in G. The reverse vertex degree cvi for a vertex vi is defined by the expression [24] cvi=Δ(G)dvi+1, where dvi is the degree of vertex vi. This concept helps in understanding the structural and spectral properties of the graph.

The energy of a graph, introduced by Ivan Gutman in 1978 [4], is a crucial measure in spectral graph theory. The graph energy E(G) is defined as the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of the graph’s adjacency matrix. Mathematically, if λ1,λ2,λ3,,λk are the eigenvalues of G, then the energy E(G) is given by E(G)=i=1k|λi|. The spectrum of a finite simple graph G consists of the eigenvalues λj of its adjacency matrix A(G), including their multiplicities. This spectrum is typically denoted as spec(G) [26].

The maximum degree matrix Me(G)=[Mij] [13] of a graph G is a square matrix where each entry Mij is defined as [Mij]={max(dvi,dvj),if vi and vj areadjacent,0,otherwise. Adiga introduced the concept of maximum degree energy M(G) for a simple connected graph G, which is the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of the maximum degree matrix Me(G).

In [17], Gutman defined the First Zagreb energy ZE1 and Second Zagreb energy ZE2 based on the first and second Zagreb topological indices. The first Zagreb matrix Z(1)(G)=[zij(1)] is given by zij(1)={dvi+dvj,if vi and vj areadjacent,0,otherwise. The first Zagreb energy ZE1(G) is the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of Z(1)(G). Similarly, the second Zagreb matrix Z(2)(G)=[zij(2)] is defined by zij(2)={dvidvj,if vi and vj areadjacent,0,otherwise. The second Zagreb energy ZE2(G) is the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of Z(2)(G).

The Randić matrix R(G)=[rij] of a graph G is defined as [rij]={1dvidvj,if vi and vj are adjacent,0,otherwise. The Randić energy ER(G) is the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of the Randić matrix R(G) [19].

The sum-connectivity matrix SC(G)=[scij] is defined as [scij]={1dvi+dvj,if vi and vj are adjacent,0,otherwise. The sum-connectivity energy ESC(G) is the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of the sum-connectivity matrix SC(G) [18].

Building on the concepts of the first and second Zagreb energies and reverse vertex degree, we define the reverse first Zagreb matrix Z(1)R and reverse second Zagreb matrix Z(2)R as follows: Z(1)R={cvi+cvj,if vi and vj areadjacent,0,otherwise. The reverse first Zagreb energy EZ1R(G) is the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of Z(1)R. Similarly, Z(2)R={cvicvj,if vi and vj areadjacent,0,otherwise. The reverse second Zagreb energy EZ2R(G) is the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of Z(2)R.

To further illustrate these concepts, consider a complete graph Kn with n2 vertices. By taking another complete graph Km with m2 vertices and joining every vertex of Kn to each vertex of Km, we obtain the join graph Jm(Kn). This resulting graph has n+m vertices and is regular with a degree d=n+m2.

This paper is organized as follows: Section 4 presents the results for various energy measures, including maximum degree energy, Randić energy, sum-connectivity energy, first Zagreb energy, second Zagreb energy, reverse first Zagreb energy, and reverse second Zagreb energy for the join graph of complete graphs. Section 5 discusses applications of these energies, while Section 6 concludes the paper.

4. Results

4.1 Maximum Degree Energy of the Join Graph of Complete Graphs

In this section, we compute the maximum degree energy of the join graph Jm(Kn). The join graph Jm(Kn) is formed by joining every vertex of Kn with each vertex of Km, resulting in a graph with n+m vertices.

Theorem 1. For m2 and n2, the maximum degree energy of the join graph Jm(Kn) is given by EM(Jm(Kn))=2(n+m1)2.

Proof. Consider the complete graph Kn with n vertices, each vertex having a degree n1. In the join graph Jm(Kn), each vertex from Kn is connected to every vertex of Km, and vice versa. Therefore, each vertex in Jm(Kn) has a degree of n+m1.

The maximum degree matrix M(Jm(Kn)) is defined as M(Jm(Kn))=[0n+m1n+m1n+m1n+m10n+m1n+m1n+m1n+m10n+m1n+m1n+m1n+m10].

To find the maximum degree energy, we need to compute the eigenvalues of M(Jm(Kn)). The characteristic polynomial of this matrix is |Λn+m1n+m1n+m1n+m1Λn+m1n+m1n+m1n+m1Λn+m1n+m1n+m1n+m1Λ|.

The spectrum of M(Jm(Kn)) is found to be Spec(M(Jm(Kn)))=((n+m1)(n+m1)2n+m11).

Thus, the maximum degree energy EM(Jm(Kn)) is calculated as EM(Jm(Kn))=(n+m1)|(n+m1)|+|(n+m1)2|=2(n+m1)2. ◻

4.2 Randić Energy of the Join Graph of Complete Graphs

In this section, we derive the Randić energy of the join graph Jm(Kn).

Theorem 2. For m2 and n2, the Randić energy of the join graph Jm(Kn) is given by ER(Jm(Kn))=2.

Proof. Consider the complete graph Kn with n vertices. The Randić matrix R(Jm(Kn)) for the join graph Jm(Kn) is defined as R(Jm(Kn))=[01(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)201(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)201(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)20].

The characteristic polynomial of this matrix is |Λ1(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)2Λ1(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)2Λ1(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)21(n+m1)2Λ|.

The spectrum of the Randić matrix R(Jm(Kn)) is Spec(R(Jm(Kn)))=(1n+m11n+m11).

Therefore, the Randić energy ER(Jm(Kn)) is given by ER(Jm(Kn))=(n+m1)|1n+m1|+|1|=2. ◻

4.3 Sum-Connectivity Energy of the Join Graph of Complete Graphs

In this section, we calculate the sum-connectivity energy of the join graph Jm(Kn). The sum-connectivity energy is derived from the sum-connectivity matrix of the join graph.

Theorem 3. For m2 and n2, the sum-connectivity energy of the join graph Jm(Kn) is given by ESC(Jm(Kn))=2(n+m1).

Proof. Consider the complete graph Kn with n vertices. In the join graph Jm(Kn), the sum-connectivity matrix SC(Jm(Kn)) is defined as SC(Jm(Kn))=[012(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)012(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)012(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)0].

The characteristic polynomial of this matrix is given by |Λ12(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)Λ12(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)Λ12(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)12(n+m1)Λ|.

The spectrum of the sum-connectivity matrix SC(Jm(Kn)) is Spec(SC(Jm(Kn)))=(12(n+m1)n+m12(n+m1)n+m11).

Therefore, the sum-connectivity energy ESC(Jm(Kn)) is given by ESC(Jm(Kn))=(n+m1)|12(n+m1)|+|n+m12(n+m1)|=2(n+m1). ◻

4.4 First Zagreb Energy of the Join Graph of Complete Graphs

In this section, we determine the first Zagreb energy of the join graph Jm(Kn). The first Zagreb energy is based on the first Zagreb matrix of the join graph.

Theorem 4. For m2 and n2, the first Zagreb energy of the join graph Jm(Kn) is given by ZE1(Jm(Kn))=4(n+m1)2.

Proof. Consider the complete graph Kn with n vertices. In the join graph Jm(Kn), the first Zagreb matrix Z(1)(Jm(Kn)) is defined as Z(1)(Jm(Kn))=[02(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)02(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)02(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)0].

The characteristic polynomial of this matrix is |Λ2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)Λ2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)Λ2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)Λ|.

The spectrum of the first Zagreb matrix Z(1)(Jm(Kn)) is Spec(Z(1)(Jm(Kn)))=(2(n+m1)2(n+m1)(n+m1)n+m11).

Thus, the first Zagreb energy ZE1(Jm(Kn)) is computed as ZE1(Jm(Kn))=(n+m1)|2(n+m1)|+|2(n+m1)(n+m1)|=4(n+m1)2. ◻

4.5 Second Zagreb Energy of the Join Graph of Complete Graphs

In this section, we calculate the second Zagreb energy of the join graph Jm(Kn). The second Zagreb energy is based on the second Zagreb matrix of the join graph.

Theorem 5. For m2 and n2, the second Zagreb energy of the join graph Jm(Kn) is given by ZE2(Jm(Kn))=2(n+m1)3.

Proof. Consider the complete graph Kn with n vertices. In the join graph Jm(Kn), the second Zagreb matrix Z(2)(Jm(Kn)) is defined as Z(2)(Jm(Kn))=[0(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)20(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)20(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)20].

The characteristic polynomial of this matrix is |Λ(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2Λ(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2Λ(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2(n+m1)2Λ|.

The spectrum of the second Zagreb matrix Z(2)(Jm(Kn)) is Spec(Z(2)(Jm(Kn)))=((n+m1)2(n+m1)3n+m11).

Thus, the second Zagreb energy ZE2(Jm(Kn)) is computed as ZE2(Jm(Kn))=(n+m1)|(n+m1)2|+|(n+m1)3|=2(n+m1)3. ◻

4.6 Reverse First Zagreb Energy of the Join Graph of Complete Graphs

In this section, we determine the reverse first Zagreb energy of the join graph Jm(Kn). The reverse first Zagreb energy is based on the reverse first Zagreb matrix of the join graph.

Theorem 6. For m2 and n2, the reverse first Zagreb energy of the join graph Jm(Kn) is given by EZ1R(Jm(Kn))=4(n+m1).

Proof. Consider the complete graph Kn with n vertices. In the join graph Jm(Kn), the reverse first Zagreb matrix Z1R(Jm(Kn)) is defined as Z1R(Jm(Kn))=[0222202222022220].

The characteristic polynomial of this matrix is |Λ2222Λ2222Λ2222Λ|.

The spectrum of the reverse first Zagreb matrix Z1R(Jm(Kn)) is Spec(Z1R(Jm(Kn)))=(22(n+m1)n+m11).

Thus, the reverse first Zagreb energy EZ1R(Jm(Kn)) is given by EZ1R(Jm(Kn))=(n+m1)|2|+|2(n+m1)|=4(n+m1). ◻

4.7 Reverse Second Zagreb Energy of the Join Graph of Complete Graphs

In this section, we calculate the reverse second Zagreb energy of the join graph Jm(Kn). The reverse second Zagreb energy is based on the reverse second Zagreb matrix of the join graph.

Theorem 7. For m2 and n2, the reverse second Zagreb energy of the join graph Jm(Kn) is given by EZ2R(Jm(Kn))=2(n+m1).

Proof. Consider the complete graph Kn with n vertices. In the join graph Jm(Kn), the reverse second Zagreb matrix Z2R(Jm(Kn)) is defined as Z2R(Jm(Kn))=[0111101111011110].

The characteristic polynomial of this matrix is |Λ1111Λ1111Λ1111Λ|.

The spectrum of the reverse second Zagreb matrix Z2R(Jm(Kn)) is Spec(Z2R(Jm(Kn)))=(1n+m1n+m11).

Thus, the reverse second Zagreb energy EZ2R(Jm(Kn)) is given by EZ2R(Jm(Kn))=(n+m1)|1|+|n+m1|=2(n+m1). ◻

References:

  1. Gutman, I., 2001. The energy of a graph: old and new results. In Algebraic Combinatorics and Applications: Proceedings of the Euroconference, Algebraic Combinatorics and Applications (ALCOMA), held in Gößweinstein, Germany, September 12–19, 1999 (pp. 196-211). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

  2. Hoffmann, R., 1963. An extended Hückel theory. I. hydrocarbons. The Journal of Chemical Physics, 39(6), pp.1397-1412.

  3. Horn, R.A. and Johnson, C.R., 2012. Matrix Analysis. Cambridge university press.

  4. Gantmakher, F.R., 2000. The Theory of Matrices (Vol. 131). American Mathematical Soc..

  5. Das, K.C., 2019. On the Zagreb energy and Zagreb Estrada index of graphs. MATCH-Communications in Mathematical and in Computer Chemistry, 82(2), pp.529-542.

  6. Rad, N.J., Jahanbani, A. and Gutman, I., 2018. Zagreb energy and Zagreb Estrada index of graphs. MATCH-Communications in Mathematical and in Computer Chemistry, 79, pp.371-386.

  7. Singh, R.P., 2014. Application of graph theory in computer science and engineering. International Journal of Computer Applications, 104(1), pp.10-13.

  8. Adiga, C. and Smitha, M., 2009. On maximum degree energy of a graph. International Journal of Contemporary Mathematical Sciences, 4(8), pp.385-396.

  9. Filipovski, S. and Jajcay, R., 2021. Bounds for the energy of graphs. Mathematics, 9(14), p.1687. MDPI.

  10. Akram, M. and Naz, S., 2018. Energy of Pythagorean fuzzy graphs with applications. Mathematics, 6(8), p.136.

  11. Pugliese, A. and Nilchiani, R., 2017. Complexity analysis of fractionated spacecraft architectures. In Aiaa Space and Astronautics Forum and Exposition (p. 5118).

  12. Das, K. C., Sorgun, S. and Xu, K., 2014. On Randic energy of graphs. MATCH Communications in Mathematical and in Computer Chemistry, 72(1), pp.227–238.

  13. Gutman, I. and Furtula, B., 2019. Graph energies and their applications. Bulletin (Académie serbe des sciences et des arts. Classe des sciences mathématiques et naturelles. Sciences mathématiques), 44, pp.29–45. JSTOR.

  14. Indulal, G. and Vijayakumar, A., 2007. Energies of some Non-regular Graphs. Journal of Mathematical Chemistry, 42, pp.377-386.

  15. Gowtham, K. J. and Swamy, N. N., 2021. On Sombor energy of graphs. Nanosystems: Physics, Chemistry, Mathematics. Retrieved from https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:239662436

  16. Ghanbari, N., 2022. On the Sombor characteristic polynomial and Sombor energy of a graph. Computational and Applied Mathematics, 41(6), p.242.

  17. Singh, R. and Patekar, S.C., 2022. On the Sombor index and Sombor energy of m-splitting graph and m-shadow graph of regular graphs. arXiv preprint arXiv:2205.09480.

  18. Patekar, S.C., Barde, S.A. and Shikare, M.M., 2019. On the average degree eigenvalues and average degree energy of graphs. J. Math. Comput. Sci., 9(1), pp.46-59.

  19. Wilson, R.J., 1979. Introduction to Graph Theory. Pearson Education India.

  20. Vaidya, S.K. and Popat, K.M., 2017. Some new results on energy of graphs. MATCH commun. Math. Comput. chem, 77, pp.589-594.

  21. Zhou, B. and Trinajstic, N., 2010. On sum-connectivity matrix and sum-connectivity energy of (molecular) graphs. Acta Chim. Slov, 57, pp.518-523.

  22. Jayanna, G.K., 2023. On maximum reverse degree energy of a graph and its chemical applicability. Bulletin of International Mathematical Virtual Institute, 13(1), pp.83-95.

  23. Jayanna, G.K., 2023. On reverse Laplacian energy of a graph. Letters in Applied NanoBioScience, 12, p.19.

  24. Bapat, R.B. and Pati, S., 2004. Energy of a Graph Is Never an Odd Integer, pp.1-4.

  25. Pirzada, S. and Gutman, I., 2008. Energy of a graph is never the square root of an odd integer. Applicable Analysis and Discrete Mathematics, pp.118-121.

  26. Nikiforov, V., 2007. The energy of graphs and matrices. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 326(2), pp.1472-1475.

  27. Meenakshi, S. and Lavanya, S., 2014. A survey on energy of graphs. Annals of Pure and Applied Mathematics, 8(2), pp.183-191.